5.0
Excellent 276 Reviews
Jetsetter Approved
This Hotel meets our standards
This hotel meets our standards, but we haven't stayed yet

What We Love

  • Hearty European-style breakfast using local produce is included in the Jetsetter rate
  • Free WiFi
  • Leisurely country amenities, including a croquet lawn and outdoor fireplace
  • Beach chairs, umbrellas, coolers and towels are provided
  • Access to a 24/7 kitchen with free coffee. tea and cocoa

What To Know

  • Minimum two night stay
  • Scoot around town on the inn's free bikes
  • Just a five-minute walk from Crescent Beach and Shelter Island Country Club
  • Although there is not restaurant, there are some options nearby
  • The inn was fully renovated in 2014
  • Free on-site parking

Amenities

  •  Babysitting
  •  Free WiFi
  •  Parking On Site
  •  Pet-friendly
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
B&B Bedroom property white living room home hardwood cottage bed frame bed sheet

Overview

Turn-of-the-century Hamptons farmhouse updated with sleek guestrooms and a knockout art collection, close to gorgeous sunset spot Crescent Beach

The Lowdown

This newly restored inn nails the 21st-century bed-and-breakfast formula, providing guests with a romantic, low-key hideaway while offering all the luxuries a modern globetrotter needs, like sustainable toiletries (from Cold Spring Apothecary), walk-in tile showers, flat-screen TVs and beds topped with goosedown comforters and colorful throw pillows from Capetown. The classic 1902 whitewashed farmhouse is filled with contemporary art, and the grounds are dotted with arresting kinetic sculptures. Guests have the run of the house, whether they want to grab a free coffee or tea from the 24/7 custom kitchen, play a lazy game of croquet, or toast marshmallows over the fire. Mornings start with a European-style breakfast buffet of fresh fruit, local organic eggs and baguettes with gourmet jams (smoked salmon and quiche get a showing on Sundays), while afternoons are bound to be spent at nearby Crescent Beach, with its gentle waves, beach bar and famed sunsets.

In the Area

Get a taste of the Hamptons culinary scene without the velvet-rope mentality at one of the island’s casual-but-top-notch dining spots. Head to 18 Bay, which is set in a 19th-century farmhouse and offers a weekly changing Italian tasting menu that features hand-rolled pasta and produce from local purveyors. Or if gathering your own provisions is more your bag, make your way to Sylvester Manor, the beloved c. 1652 homestead whose organic farm and arts and education center are a hub for locals. Talking of the arts, try to catch a concert at the Shelter Island campus of the Itzhak Perlman Music Program, which nurtures talented young music students. Performances are conducted by Perlman himself, who sometimes joins in on violin.

How to Get There

SEVEN – Shelter Island Guest House
7 Stearns Point Road
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 United States

Reviews

Super B&B
Docbarkin

Wonderful B&B with upscale accommodations
Warm and friendly staff that go out of there way to make your stay amazing Spotlessly clean with extreme attention to detail and ambiance
A must stay when you visit Shelter Island
What a wonderful Birthday celebration weekend!

Very nice Bed and Breakfast
markusb872

Very clean bed and breakfast
Great service
Nice rooms, quite, very clean and comfortable
Very good breakfast
Free parking
Highly recommend
I assume the best place to stay on Shelter Island
Close to the northern ferry

outstanding
billfromvg

My wife and I recently stayed for two nights while attending a wedding. We are both retired architects. Seven is a designer's delight. Everything from the hardware and plumbing fixtures to the plates and mugs were carefully chosen and all were nicely designed. It was a great pleasure in every way. Also - good coffee.