95%
Members Recommend
4.5
Very Good 309 Reviews
Jetsetter Verified
This Hotel meets our standards
Our editors have been here and it has met our standards

What We Love

  • Suites are vast, starting at 1,400 square feet
  • Upon request, the hotel can arrange nearby activities, such as surfing lessons and snorkeling the coral reefs north of Rincon
  • The infinity pool overlooks the Caribbean Sea
  • For dinner, choose between the elegant Aaron and the more casual, open-air Blue Room restaurant

What To Know

  • It’s best to fly to Mayaguez rather than drive from San Juan
  • Children 17 and under are not permitted in the suites
  • The daily meal plan for breakfast and dinner is pricey; it’s a 15-minute drive to other restaurants in the area
  • The dress code at Restaurant Aaron is long pants, collared shirt, closed-toed shoes — tie and jacket not required

Amenities

  •  Babysitting
  •  Bar
  •  Free WiFi
  •  Gym
  •  Handicap-accessible
  •  Parking On Site
  •  Pet-friendly
  •  Pool
  •  Restaurant
  •  Spa
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
Luxury Resort tree plant building property house Courtyard home Architecture arch hacienda Villa mansion palm bushes Garden altar colonnade

Overview

The Review

Opened in 1987, this Relais & Chateaux property may not be a part of the ever-expanding ranks of up-to-the-minute design hotels, but what it lacks in flashiness it makes up for with attentive service, a quiet atmosphere and a location where the Caribbean is literally at your feet.

Spread over seven beachfront acres, the Horned Dorset Primavera is made up of whitewashed stucco buildings — outfitted with red tile roofs, Moorish arches and enclosed balconies — set either directly on or behind an oceanfront seawall, meaning the second-story rooms make you feel as if you’re at the helm of a cruise ship.

{“type”:”img-inline”,”src”:”/static/images/product/properties/editorialreviews/10017/pgal-79695-1295981879-full.jpg”,”width”:”275″,”caption”:”The 39-room Horned Dorset Primavera is located near Rincon, on the west coast of Puerto Rico.”}The smaller Primavera suites are clustered on the southwest side of the property, while the newer Horned Dorset Residences are located on the northeast side. At 1,400 square feet, the suites are appointed with canopy beds, teak furniture and Spanish marble floors; the bathrooms are enormous and have multiple showerheads and oversize bathtubs. Most of the suites have private terraces or balconies and outdoor plunge pools.

The vibe here skews to the formal (gentlemen are encouraged to wear a jacket and tie at Restaurant Aaron, the hotel’s French dining room), but this doesn’t interfere with the Horned Dorset’s top priority: relaxation. The beach is tiny, secluded, and looks out on a rocky shoreline — perfect for sunbathing with a cocktail in hand.

Beyond the beach, the hotel makes it easy for travelers to disconnect (you won’t find televisions or tech gadgets in the suites). And while it does take a while to actually reach the hotel, you’d be hard pressed to find a more scenic or tranquil spot in all of Puerto Rico.

How to Get There

Horned Dorset Primavera
PR-429, Km 3
Rincon, 00677 Puerto Rico

Reviews

4.5 Very Good 309 Reviews
Beautiful place!
Reviewed 2 weeks ago

This is a great hotel and beautiful place. Very nice and private rooms,great service. The restaurant is everything you would expect from a fancy restaurant in a beautiful oceanfront setting. Delicious food and great service.

Oh la la
Reviewed 3 weeks ago

Picture a wealthy Indian merchant doing business in PR in the 1940's settling his family into a fabulous seaside Villa via their own private railroad siding! That level of elegance is alive today in this hostelry cum restaurant. With hand-painted murals covering the walls of one room and a white-tablecloth, heavy hotel silver, marble floored dining room, you will feel like an honored guest at the finest residence anywhere. The professional grade servers are knowledgeable and provide the highest level of table service without being stuffy. There are three multi-course menus plus a tasting menu (from $70 - 125) and there was no problem substituting. Each dish was as good as you have eaten anywhere. Totally worth it.

Simply Breathtaking
Reviewed 2 months ago

The Horned Dorset is an extremely special hotel. My wife and I have stayed there before the storm and after the storm... It is incredible how they made such full rebound and even made improvements.. We dined at the restaurant and enjoy our breathtaking villa with our plunge pool. Almost all of the staff remains the same from the last 5+ years so it was nice to see some friendly faces. They even remembered us by name!

Rincon in general was immaculate.. It is cleaning and has more of an identity than most of San Juan. Several restaurants and beach bars have popped up since our last visit. It really was impressive to see. Looking forward to our next visit!

P.S. Make sure to visit the lighthouse when you visit.

Not worth the expense
Reviewed 2 months ago

We only stayed one night here (thank goodness)! While the grounds are secluded and beautiful, the property is in desperate need of some TLC. Our shower only put out scalding hot water, our private plunge pool was absolutely disgusting (as was the main pool), and the buildings need some clean-up and painting. I’m very disappointed!

Gorgeous but proceed with caution
Reviewed 3 months ago

This resort is gorgeous, but I have no idea how it is going to survive. The resort is for sale, it is in bankruptcy, and now some of the units are not occupiable due to the hurricane. If you look at the images on the web, you’ll see some of the units right on the water, balanced on a seawall. Well, that seawall took quite a beating during the hurricane and only some of them are functioning. We were lucky enough to stay in one of them. But, there are other units available. And, the landscaping is still as beautiful as it looks in the photos.

The other problem the resort has is that there are newer adjacent units, individually owned, that have the same look and feel, but that are rented out on the apartment rental sites. These have fully functioning kitchens, similar plunge pools, etc. What I didn’t like about the resort units is that the website describes them as having kitchenettes. But, they really don’t have kitchenettes. They have a fridge and a microwave and a room that looks like a kitchen, but it doesn’t have a single thing that you’d normally find in a kitchen. There isn’t a plate, a wine glass, a coffee maker, nothing. Even the cooktop has been disabled. I expected to be able to make some of my meals in this space, so after going to the grocery store, I went to the discount store and bought two plates, two cups, a sharp knife, and some paper towel. The decision to rid the units of functioning kitchens makes no sense to me. There are apartments for rent right next door that share the resort amenities that have functioning kitchens. Other than being able to be right on the seawall, I don’t know why people wouldn’t rent them instead. (Maybe they have a deal with the on-site restaurant. We didn’t eat there because it was stuffy and expensive.)

The other thing I felt the resort was missing was stuff for the beach. It sure would have been nice to find chairs and an umbrella that we could take to the various beaches in Rincón. Again, many of the apartment rentals come with this type of equipment and also include boogie boards, noodles, etc. (We didn’t hang out at the beach here because there isn’t much of it left. During medium-to-high tide, you can’t use it.)

We enjoyed our three nights here. The bed was large (it really needs king-sized pillows, however) and comfy. The plunge pool and sunsets were divine. The gardens were lush and inviting. And, we made friends with an iguana who wouldn’t leave the road when we wanted to drive on by. But, I can’t give the resort my strongest recommendation because of the problems I detailed here.