4.0
Very Good 35 Reviews
Jetsetter Verified
This Hotel meets our standards
Our editors have been here and it has met our standards

What We Love

  • Daily breakfast is included in the Jetsetter rate
  • Free WiFi
  • The hotel’s art gallery features an eclectic mix of contemporary artworks
  • Afternoon cocktails on the pretty garden patio
  • A game and movie room, both of which have a cool, loungey feel

What To Know

  • No guests under 21
  • The hotel aims to attract a hip, young jetset crowd
  • Fido will have to stay at home; the Gallery Hotel isn’t pet-friendly
  • Greenport is a sleepy beach town, but it offers much in the way of recreational activities

Amenities

  •  Free WiFi
  •  Parking On Site
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
chair property building wooden porch home house cottage backyard outdoor structure Balcony Villa condominium Deck

Overview

A vibrant pastiche hotel in Greenport, Long Island, with spacious guestrooms, an idyllic garden patio and a contemporary art gallery

The Look

Tucked between sleepy Main Street and Central Avenue in Greenport, the newly opened Gallery Hotel is an eclectic jewel box of a boutique property. Though the exterior of the shingle-style building has preserved the town’s old whaling port charm, the inside daringly breaks from that tradition, exuding a colorful South Beach meets Mediterranean feel. Expect vibrant abstract paintings, funky map art and summery mixed pattern furnishings against stark white walls. Select antiques nod to Greenport’s heritage, while the bold decor (a candy stripe couch here, fun neon wall art there) suggests a whimsical tropical influence.

Bed and Bath

The restful guestrooms temper the funky aesthetic of the common areas with calming tones that recall sea and sand: eggshell, teal and seafoam green. Oak floors, natural fiber furnishings and crisp white bed linens give the rooms a barefoot cottage vibe, while the bathrooms are understated, with rainfall showers and Philosophy bath products.

Beyond

Rise early to enjoy the continental breakfast spread — Greek yogurt, pastries, a variety of fruit, sandwiches and cappuccino — in the hotel’s sunlit café. If you prefer to eat alfresco, make your way to the lush, flower-lined garden patio, where you can kick back and relax under chic umbrellas. In the event of showers, challenge a friend to a chess match in the retro-inspired game room, or head to the movie room to catch a flick.

In the Area

Start your day by going back in time at Greenport’s sidewalk boutiques. Times Vintage, conveniently located just steps from the hotel, is packed to the gills with a vast selection of retro art, vintage clothing and antique furniture and jewelry. Across the street is Beall & Bell, a favorite antiques store among big name Hamptons designers and magazine editors looking to score unique heirlooms and period pieces. From there catch the ferry to Shelter Island and take a guided paddling tour of the isle’s protected creeks and scenic harbors through Shelter Island Kayak Tours. You’ll have worked up an appetite, so head back to Greenport and treat yourself to a feast of saffron risotto, grilled steak fiorentina and homemade pasta at the romantic, Italian-accented Caci North Fork restaurant, and don’t leave without trying their all-natural homemade gelato. End your night by chatting with locals and sipping expertly crafted cocktails and local wines at the hipster haven Brix & Rye speakeasy.

How to Get There

The Gallery Hotel
437 Main St # 441
Greenport, NY 11944-1427 United States

Reviews

4.0 Very Good 35 Reviews
Wonderful
Reviewed 1 week ago

The wonderful and friendly staff will make you feel right at home. The hotel rooms have all the essentials and the beds are cozy and comfortable. The hotel itself is full of areas that you can claim as your own space. The retro eclectic decor will take you back to a MadMen era. I loved everything!!! 🍸

Manhattan Style With a NOFO Soul!
Reviewed 1 month ago

Just home after spending two nights here to celebrate our wedding anniversary, and we couldn’t have left happier. Small hotel with easy access to everything in Greeport village had a Lower East Side design vibe, but unpretentious service that was warm and friendly without being obtrusive. The room was light and airy, with a super comfortable bed, soft sheets, fluffy towels and robes, great water pressure in the shower, air conditioning that worked well and quietly, and a 46- inch Sony flatscreen TV. Minibar prices were very reasonable, and lively art is all over the place. It has some of the most fun and whimsical public spaces I’ve ever seen in a hotel, including a movie viewing room, another room dedicated to the enjoyment of vinyl records, a second floor gaming parlor with chess and backgammon sets, and an incredibly beautiful garden for guest use. Art and pop culture artifacts were everywhere, but in such a stylish way. We were warmly checked in by Christine, who showed us to our room and explained all of its features. We had a few minor room issues - a CO2 detector that was a little sensitive, etc - but they were handled quickly and thoroughly. The restaurant - Kon Tiki - has a cool Polynesian theme and a great looking menu, but we already had dinner plans. Went there for a nightcap twice - young gent who seemed to be in charge was terrific, but bartender could smile more and make eye contact a little more quickly. Restaurant was also on the warm side. Loved this hotel though, and look forward to returning.

Excellent Customer Service
Reviewed 2 months ago

For a budget hotel the hotel was very nice. The most important thing, comfortable beds and clean rooms. I had an amazing night sleep. The staff were super helpful and couldn't do enough to help me, including an early check in and late check out. If you are looking for good accomodation that won't break your bank, the Gallery Hotel is the place

Sophisticated & Hip
Reviewed 3 months ago

If you want to stay in Greenport and are looking for an adults-only, hip and relaxing niche hotel, The Gallery is the spot. Impeccably decorated, clean and comfortable, The Gallery offers various rooms to relax in, both inside and outside the hotel. Our room was beautiful and we enjoyed the lounge, bistro and garden areas before turning in for the night. This is a nice option for those looking for a sophisticated and art-filled experience on the North Fork.

Adorable Vivacious Hotel for Decor Lovers
Reviewed 3 months ago

Such personality! I loved this hotel's charm and vivid decor. I could live in the parlour and the garden makes me envious!
Our room overlooked the garden and was plenty of space for the two of us. Quiet but right in the center of the town, close to shops and restaurants.

Definitely book the room facing the garden and visit the in house restaurant for yummy Asian inspired food.