91%
Members Recommend
4.5
Very Good 560 Reviews
Jetsetter Verified
This Hotel meets our standards
Our editors have been here and it has met our standards

What We Love

  • Idyllic rural setting on 75 acres overlooking the Hudson River
  • Classic inn amenities: wood-burning fireplaces, floral decor and homemade scones and local jams
  • Boutique size with resort-style amenities: farm-to-table restaurant and cooking classes; gym, tennis courts and the luxe all-natural spa
  • READ MORE: Find your perfect Upstate NY getaway?

What To Know

  • Riverbirch and Riverknoll Houses have more privacy, but they’re a stroll from the Main House; Standard Rooms in the Main House are on the small side
  • WiFi is available in common areas of the Main House and some houses
  • Children 15 and under are not permitted in the Main Inn or spa and pool area
  • Pets are not permitted in Standard Rooms (located in the Main Inn)

Amenities

  •  Free WiFi
  •  Gym
  •  Parking On Site
  •  Pet-friendly
  •  Pool
  •  Restaurant
  •  Spa
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
B&B Inn Lounge Outdoor Activities Waterfront Wellness living room property home hardwood flooring wood flooring cottage rug

Overview

On 75 rural acres just 90 minutes from NYC, this cozy inn offers pampering spa time and hearty farm-to-table dinners

The Look

On 75 rural acres alongside the Hudson River, the inn is a country charmer with all the modern trimmings. Shades of white, cream and taupe, wood floors and antique furniture define the Main House, where guests mingle for breakfast and afternoon tea (and reliable WiFi) every day. Settle into one of the rust-red leather sofas next to the roaring fire, or wander the lush grounds, which are filled with ponds, rustic outbuildings and the namesake falls.

Bed & Bath

Rooms and suites are spread across the 18th-century Main House and four free-standing guesthouses. On a cliff with river views, North Cottage is a charming two-bed stone and wood house with a cozy cottage feel. City slickers with more contemporary tastes, especially those traveling with a group, will prefer Riverbirch House for its sleek modern style, 5,000 square feet of space and setting in a grove of birch trees.

Beyond

Just a few steps from the Main House, Henry’s Farm to Table Restaurant (closed on Monday and Tuesday) uses local ingredients on its inventive, ever changing menu. Nosh on local delicacies including a Hudson Valley Cattle Company strip steak with roasted butternut squash, or a selection of pizzas (the white sauce with apple and cheddar cheese is divine). A highlight of any stay is visiting the on-site Millstone Farm, which grows many of the organic fruits, vegetables and herbs used in the restaurant — I was instantly smitten by the resident doe-eyed alpacas. And for sybarites, the lovely spa focuses on natural and organic products. Try the Buttermilk Body Bliss, which uses Fiji cane sugar and drift nut oils to buff away dry skin, followed by a scalp massage with warm oils.

In the Area

Just 80 miles from New York City, the Hudson River Valley gets city folk back to nature. Admire the river and valley floor from the Walkway Over the Hudson, the longest elevated pedestrian bridge in the world, or make the 20-minute drive to Franklin D. Roosevelt Presidential Library and Museum, America’s first presidential library. Active types should head to Minnewaska State Park or Mohonk Preserve for hiking trails, while shoppers can browse the fun and funky retail outlets in New Paltz, around 20 minutes away, or Woodbury Commons. Everyone should make time for the extraordinary Storm King Art Center — one of the world’s leading sculpture parks, with enormous, modern works spread across a sprawling 500-acre site.

How to Get There

Buttermilk Falls Inn
220 North Road
Milton, NY 12547 United States

Reviews

4.5 Very Good 560 Reviews
mini moon
Reviewed 3 weeks ago

We came here for a mini moon after our wedding. Just what we needed. Only 1.5 hrs from the city, quiet and relaxing.

Check in/ out was smooth.
Breakfast was delicious and there was always abundant food.
Spa & deep tissue massage was excellent (very reasonable too!). Started on time, and my masseuse Adrienne was awesome.
We stayed in the Riverknoll Downs- and agree with some of the other reviews about the noise upstairs (people walking around is loud) and the trains- though I used a ear plug at night and slept like a baby, and the upstairs footsteps were only really noticeable here and there... but we also live in the city so we are somewhat immune to that kind of thing.

We mostly did a lot of nothing- relaxing by the fireplace, reading books and drinking champagne, wine, etc. Exactly what we needed.
We did take a walk around the property and saw the animals, and on our way back stopped and did a 1.5hr mini hike to Franny Reese State Park which is only a 5min drive away.

We loved this place and we will definitely be back.

Relaxing babymoon
Reviewed 4 weeks ago

Since this was our last vacation before our baby arrives in February, my husband and I decided to treat ourselves to a weekend at Buttermilk Falls. It was worth the splurge and we thoroughly enjoyed a relaxing stay.

We booked the Juniper suite with the babymoon package that is advertised on the website. This included massages, boxed lunch at the spa, water bottles, a onesie & stuffed animal. We were happy to spend the majority of our weekend on the property. We spent half a day at the spa & pool, went for a few walks, and lounged in our room next to the fireplace. We weren't planning to dine at Henry's, but luckily it happened to be restaurant week so we went for it!

Overall, the property is beautiful, staff was friendly, food was delicious, and we had a great experience. Our only complaint is that, for an expensive room, the bed was not very comfortable and the pillows were lumpy.

Mix of very nice and not so good
Reviewed 1 month ago

This is a quaint place that is quiet, relaxing and situated beautifully. The room was very nice (Rook's Nest guest cottage). The restaurant for dinner Henry's was very nice and good. Highly recommended. It's sort of a B&B meets a spa. Except for that warm welcome and attention you usually get at places like this, did not exist. Staff was not quite rude, but almost. Meaning we felt ignored at best. When you arrive or walk into the spa nobody greets you. The place seems to be run by a bunch of very young people who have not been trained in friendly customer service and don't have the sense of ownership that a family-run business would have. The yoga instructor seemed frantic to begin by 7:45. My wife and I were the only attendees of the class and we said don't worry about it, and we were finishing our coffee. She was running around like crazy and explained that it must start on time so that the spa could open by 9. She seemed scared. It was an unrelaxing way to begin yoga. The class was at poolside (indoor) and was very cramped (with only 2 of us!!). I did not enjoy it at all. My wife thought it was fine. My wife later went to work out at the exercise room and it smelled so bad she didn't stay.

Other pluses are the breakfast both mornings was terrific. They gave us a late check-out but didn't write it down. When I checked out the young woman immediately started explaining how she generally needs to charge for a full extra day since we didn't check out on time. I explained that I asked for the late checkout and they said it was no problem since nobody was checking into that room. The other young woman sitting next too her, who gave us the late checkout, turned to her and said I was sorry. Nobody said sorry to us though. They just don't seem to get customer service at all.

Wedding!!
Reviewed 1 month ago

We chose Buttermilk for our wedding. We were having a very small destination wedding and wanted some fall color. Many venues we looked at wanted LOTS of money, even for a small wedding. We found the perfect spot in Buttermilk Falls Inn and Spa!!

We had the wedding on the lower patio overlooking the Hudson River and it was spectacular! Kathleen, our contact, went above and beyond for us at every step. She had to deal with a bride and groom who were thousands of miles away but she was patient and attentive to our every need. I didn't expect the level of customer service we received from her! It was amazing and I credit her with helping make our day so very wonderful!

The grounds are breathtaking, the rooms are amazing (we stayed in two-Maynor Flats and Grand Laurel) and beds super comfortable.

They offer an afternoon tea complete with sweet and savory food options. It's a perfect snack to tide you over until dinner.

I had a spa treatment and would highly recommend checking it out when you are there. Fantastic amenities and customer service!

We had our wedding dinner at Henry's but I will review that separately.

The breakfasts were absolutely amazing and we woke up each morning excited to see what our options would be. Unlike some B and B's they offer a hot breakfast choice that is cooked to order so it's much more like a restaurant setting. Food was outstanding!!! Jenni does an amazing job!!

We are looking forward to our 1st anniversary trip and are already thinking about booking now because we know this place books up quickly during the fall color!

Beautiful Views!
Reviewed 1 month ago

Stunning views, especially during fall foliage. Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa truly deserves 5 stars. the only reason why I am giving it 4 stars is because the beds are horrible and uncomfortable. I am sure if they replace the beds, they will get many returning customers, such as myself. It would be great if they also had more activities around the resort.