90%
Members Recommend
4.5
Very Good 308 Reviews
Jetsetter Verified
This Hotel meets our standards
Our editors have been here and it has met our standards

What We Love

  • A hot breakfast is included in the Jetsetter rate
  • Top-notch service
  • Enjoying a pint, a bite and plenty of historical ambience at adjacent Grain House restaurant

What To Know

  • Some rooms face a parking lot or highway; Courtyard Rooms are quietest
  • The inn is popular with business travelers during the work week and hosts weddings on weekends
  • The inn’s colonial style isn’t for everybody

Amenities

  •  Bar
  •  Free WiFi
  •  Handicap-accessible
  •  Restaurant
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
Bedroom Historic Inn Outdoor Activities property living room house home hardwood cottage recreation room wood flooring farmhouse

Overview

Home-style hospitality and a pitch-perfect pub with Revolutionary War cred amid the rolling Somerset Hills

The Look

The small mill erected by Samuel Lewis in 1768 in the Somerset Hills fed George Washington’s Continental Army during the bitter winter of 1779 and laid the tracks for the Olde Mill Inn’s home-style hospitality and early American style. A roaring fire welcomes guests in the smallish lobby, which is done up in colonial manor decor with cherrywood-paneled walls. There are public spaces on the various landings of the somewhat confusing multilevel building; a paneled library is laden with classic tomes and period bric-a-brac, while the walls of the formal piano lounge are hung with portraits and a heavy dose of horse-centric works. Breakfast is served daily in the sunny conservatory, which has picture windows that look out over a courtyard.

Bed and Bath

All 102 guestrooms and suites have a homey vibe that is comfortable but not necessarily for those with more modern tastes. The palette leans toward forest green, maroon and rose, and there are floral patterned drapery, brass fixtures and wood furnishings. The bathrooms have been updated and feature smallish tub-shower combos and Gilchrist & Soames toiletries. The inn may stake its reputation on its colonial-era charms, but all the mod cons required by today’s road warriors are readily available, including flat-screen TVs, Keurig coffeemakers, free WiFi and big desks with plenty of power outlets.

Beyond

The original storehouse for the mill that fed the Continental Army is still keeping bellies full and spirits high in its latest incarnation as the Grain House restaurant. Sidle up to the bar in the Coppertop Pub for a pint of Coppertop Ale, brewed for the restaurant by New Jersey’s own Climax Brewing Company, or set up camp at a table by a fire in a centuries-old stone fireplace. Hearty fare includes classics like a rich French onion soup, Coppertop Ale–battered fish and chips, and slow-roasted meatloaf wrapped in applewood-smoked bacon.

In the Area

This neck of New Jersey was a linchpin of colonial America’s economy and an important base for the Continental Army. Morristown National Historical Park is composed of four areas at which colonial history and the Revolutionary War are memorialized for history buffs. George Washington and his army spent a frigid winter at Jockey Hollow, and today you can go for a hike and tour the soldiers’ barracks. Not far from there, the New Jersey Brigade Encampment Area is the site where New Jersey soldiers enlisted in the Continental Army and later camped. The park is also home to Washington’s headquarters and the Ford Museum, where the Revolutionary War is brought back to life.

How to Get There

The Olde Mill Inn
225 US Hwy 202
Basking Ridge, NJ 07920 United States

Reviews

4.5 Very Good 308 Reviews
Great Experience!!
Reviewed 2 weeks ago

Hosted our top level executives at the Grain House for dinner. They absolutely love it. Everything was perfect - food was great. The staff was very professional. Working with Ellie was wonderful - she is very attentive and follows up to make sure she has all the information needed to make your event special for your guests.

Wonderful Experience
Reviewed 3 weeks ago

We have stayed here numerous times and always have a wonderful experience. The entire hotel is spotless clean and the rooms are beyond comfortable. I love that they have a small fridge and a coffee maker which allowed us to bring milk rather than use the powdered creamer that was supplied. The courtyard is beautiful and the breakfast plentiful. Definately recommed the romance package.

Visit June 22, 2018
Reviewed 3 weeks ago

I went to The Olde Mill inn for a wedding two days ago and it was beautiful. Everything from start to finish. I walked into the hotel and it was gorgeous but had an old feeling to it. The room was gorgeous and very spacious. The wedding ceremony was help outside and it was very intimate. Cocktail hour had a wonderful array of foods and my favorite was their French onion bites! The reception was in their beautiful ballroom. Check in and check out were super easy and smoothly. I would 100% go back!

Great stay! Great Wedding!
Reviewed 2 months ago

This place was great. It was a little confusing navigating inside the hotel. Bed was comfortable and room was clean. Food at the Grain House was great. Staff was very professional and did a great job servicing the wedding we attended. The continental breakfast was good. We had a lovely time at this hotel.

Wedding
Reviewed 2 months ago

This hotel is just fantastic the rooms are decorated beautifully the staff is friendly warm and accommodating. The facilities are wonderful and the food is really excellent. I would stay here on a weekend getaway next.