Members Recommend
Very Good 1080 Reviews
Jetsetter Verified
This Hotel meets our standards
Our editors have been here and it has met our standards

What We Love

  • Cozy cottages with vaulted ceilings, washer/dryers and private patios
  • Grilled oysters at on-site Henry’s, one of the island’s best pubs
  • The view of the Edgartown Lighthouse from the porch at sunset
  • It’s just a short walk from downtown Edgartown’s historic mansions

What To Know

  • The secluded location is a 10-minute walk from Edgartown
  • The hotel has a fitness center
  • Rooms in the Mayhew Building offer views of the pool and the gardens
  • The kids' club is seasonal


  •  Babysitting
  •  Bar
  •  Free WiFi
  •  Gym
  •  Handicap-accessible
  •  Kids Club
  •  Parking On Site
  •  Pool
  •  Restaurant
  •  Room Service
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
Bedroom Classic Fireplace Waterfront property home living room cottage Suite


Martha’s Vineyard charmer with a seaside-chic look, two restaurants and views of Edgartown Lighthouse

The Look

On Starbuck’s Neck, a stretch of land at the end of Water Street, the Harbor View Hotel has one of the most iconic and picturesque views on Martha’s Vineyard, and it’s just a short walk from downtown Edgartown’s historic mansions. Nab one of the turquoise rocking chairs on the expansive wraparound porch and admire the 45-foot tall Edgartown Lighthouse and waterfront scenery.

Bed and Bath

Originally built in 1891, the 114 guestrooms are divided between two buildings that house single rooms and several cottage suites. Sand-colored couches, red checkerboard-pattern bedspreads, vaulted ceilings with wrought iron chandeliers and working fireplaces characterize the rooms. The cottages come with washers and dryers, ample lounging space and patios that overlook the gardens, while the neutral bathrooms have over-tub showers, luxe amenities and plush robes.


Year-round Henry’s Hotel Bar, an Old World–style pub hidden behind the main dining room, is a favorite with both guests and locals for its grilled oysters and modern seafood dishes, as well as the open ocean views. Water Street, the hotel’s larger restaurant, offers a stellar Sunday brunch, which includes a raw bar, carving stations, waffles, cod cakes, omelets and a bakery’s worth of homemade pastries. It’s just the fuel you need to start exploring idyllic Martha’s Vineyard.

In the Area

The island’s private beaches require passes only during the summer, so plan a hike to spots like Lucy Vincent to get a glimpse of what most visitors miss. Or have a bike delivered by Edgartown Bicycles, and pedal west to explore the tiny, picturesque harbor at Menemsha and the breathtaking Aquinnah Cliffs at Gay Head. For advanace trip planning, visit TicketsMV and get a leg up on upcoming events, festivals and concerts in the area.

How to Get There

Harbor View Hotel
131 N Water Street Marthas Vineyard
Edgartown, MA 02539 United States


4.0 Very Good 1080 Reviews
Great Location and Grounds
Reviewed 3 days ago

Stayed here for a couple of days while attending an onsite wedding. We stayed in the back building, which is more of a traditional hotel/motel setup. The rooms could use a bit of an update for sure but I thought the beds were comfortable and the bathrooms were clean and had adequate hot water. The only complaint about the room was that the TV reception was pretty spotty... especially in this day and age. The grounds and pool were very well kept and we found the staff to be both friendly and helpful.

Very overpriced and overrated!
Reviewed 3 days ago

Our stay here was a big let down unfortunately. I had high expectations of this hotel because it is highly rated overall on most websites and I assumed when you’re paying close to $400/night the hotel will deliver..not so much. My first impression was not very positive at all, I walk up to the check in desk and the gentleman behind the desk did not bother making eye contact with me and said he will help me in just a moment in a manner that made me feel like I was a nuisance to him. Another gentleman approached the desk and he was instructed by the first gentleman I interacted with to check me in. The two exchanged very sarcastic remarks to each other, one saying let me take care of this chaos(referring to a stack of papers) and you can create your own chaos. The second gentleman proceeded to check me in and again I felt like I was a nuisance to him as well...overall not a great start and I did not feel welcomed at all. If anything I walked away from that concerned and wondering what kind of place this is...I told myself to give it a chance and I tried,however, from that point things didn’t improve very much at all unfortunately. When we walked into our room I immediately smelled a very musty odor and noticed some stains on the carpet and a lot of chipped paint throughout the walls of the room. I didn’t give it much thought being that we are only staying here one night(thankfully!) and my husband and I were in a rush to get to concierge so we can make some plans for the day..we get to concierge and nobody is there. I ask the Bell hop if he knew when she would return and he wasn’t sure so he asked the gentleman at the check in counter where she may be and he said he thought she went to the bathroom but he wasn’t quite sure. I decided to wait around for her..a good 10-15 minutes goes by and still no concierge, I ask again when/if she is returning and both Bell hop and gentleman at the check in counter said they do not know. My 1 year old daughter was becoming impatient so I decided to ask the Bell hop and the gentleman at check in some questions and they gave me some advice on where to go/things to do..they did the best job they could but certainly not the way a person in concierge would(and I wouldn’t expect them to it’s not their job) I have to mention the Bell hop was an absolute sweetheart, very welcoming and warm..so I felt a bit better about things...that’s until we got back to our room that night and I got a closer look at the bathroom..it was FILTHY! The vent in the bathroom had so much dust built up on it I wonder if it’s ever been cleaned, the grout along the tub on the floor was moldy and dusty as my pictures show. This is completely unacceptable and is certainly not indicative of a 3.5 Star hotel that is charging $400/night. Once I see filth like this all bets are off, I would never recommend anyone to stay here, it’s completely overpriced and overrated.

Do not stay in building behind main hotel.
Reviewed 5 days ago

The main building is lovely and has a beautiful view, but can't vouch for rooms.
Back building is horrible.
Constant damp feeling with mildew odor, which is concerning to breath. TV did not work consistently, and half the channels (the movies) had no sound. Could not plug bedside lamp into outlet as headboard is attached to wall, so that was there just for looks.
My minor child was traumatized by hearing couple next door, doing couple things as walls are so thin.
Overall so disappointing for $500 a night.
Front desk did comp us one night, which they should have. Building needs complete renovation.

Great Place Centrally Located
Reviewed 6 days ago

The Hotel is within two blocks of ferry and one block from bike rental. Hotel serves continental breakfast and encourages those guests to take it up to the cupola. Great view of the harbor. The hotel also ha a couple of great restaurants within two blocks. For breakfast (if not doing continental at the hotel) try Waterside Market. It’s a Triple D destination. For dinner try La Soffitta. Great Italian food in a cozy setting.
Great time, great rooms, great location.

Best Location
Reviewed 1 week ago

This is a great place to stay. The building has a lot of character. The staff is very attentive. The view from the front is beautiful. It's a short walk from the stores and restaurants.
I enjoyed the front porch and the rocking chairs. It is very relaxing to sit there and watch the boats move in and out.

Please note, that the hotel is expected to close for renovation at the end of the month.