80%
Members Recommend
3.5
Average 156 Reviews
Jetsetter Verified
This Hotel meets our standards
Our editors have been here and it has met our standards

What We Love

  • Within walking distance of the harbor, a Colonial-style village and a nature preserve
  • Sunset harbor views from the cottages
  • Dinner at the on-site Mirabelle Restaurant (try the croque madame)
  • Excellent Scotch selection at the Tavern bar
  • READ MORE: Where to eat, play and shop in NY

What To Know

  • Mirabelle restaurant is open for dinner Tuesdays through Sundays
  • Located an hour and a half from Manhattan, via the Stony Brook stop along the Long Island Rail Road
  • Better for those looking for a quiet stay
  • WiFi is spotty
  • There’s no pool or spa (though there is a spa in town)

Amenities

  •  Bar
  •  Free WiFi
  •  Gym
  •  Handicap-accessible
  •  Restaurant
  •  Spa
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
Dining Drink Eat Inn restaurant function hall white brunch Bar

Overview

The Review

With a stay at Three Village Inn in Stony Brook, you’ll be in the historical district and convenient to Avalon Park and Preserve and Stony Brook University. This hotel is within close proximity of Long Island Museum of American Art, History, and Carriages and Harmony Vineyards.

Make yourself at home in one of the 25 air-conditioned rooms featuring flat-screen televisions. Your room comes with a Select Comfort bed. Complimentary wired and wireless Internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming provides entertainment. Private bathrooms with shower/tub combinations feature complimentary toiletries and hair dryers.

Treat yourself with body treatments and facials. Additional amenities include complimentary wireless Internet access, wedding services, and a fireplace in the lobby.

Grab a bite to eat at one of the hotel’s dining establishments, which include 2 restaurants and a coffee shop/café. Quench your thirst with your favorite drink at a bar/lounge. A complimentary full breakfast is included.

Featured amenities include complimentary high-speed (wired) Internet access, a 24-hour business center, and complimentary newspapers in the lobby. Event facilities at this hotel consist of conference space and meeting rooms. A train station pick-up service is provided at no charge.

How to Get There

Three Village Inn
150 Main Street
Stony Brook, NY 11790 United States

Reviews

3.5 Average 156 Reviews
Won’t return
Reviewed 1 month ago

We live in the area but had never eaten here (although our children have attended several catered events). We decided to take advantage of Restaurant Week and have dinner. The food was good but we were not impressed by the service. We were placed in the bar by the fireplace and felt completely ignored. We had ordered dinners and gotten our appetizers and then waited for over 1/2 hour for the second course. I finally asked another server if he could locate the young woman who was taking care of our table and still didn’t get a response. I went to the front desk and asked about our meal and finally got a response. We were told that our server had a medical issue. I understand that but don’t appreciate the fact that our table was completely ignored. I had the mussels with fries. The mussels were tasty but the fries were cold when we got our meal. The restaurant also provides one slice of bread with the meal. I asked for additional and I was given one more slice of bread. Nothing was offered to my husband. We will be giving this restaurant a pass in the future.

Old property and shows it
Reviewed 1 month ago

I really like the "feel" of this place, and the atmosphere, but upkeep-wise and maintenance-wise, it's terrible and borderline dangerous.
Example: leaving the tavern and dining room area to go to the cottages, one exits via two doors to a small patio area and a path leading to the cottages. The second door has three hinges. Two were completely ripped out of the door, just hanging in the wind. The door was only held on by the middle hinge which looked like it was about to fail. Not safe!
The cottages were well worn. The steps to some rooms were so saggy they seemed about to tumble down, bounced and felt unsafe. Some of the bricks were missing. The steps to our cottage were very questionable - the first one was so high another step should have been in front.
But it had atmosphere. Mold and dampness everywhere. How about a good clean-up? Maybe some new paint. If not, this place will just fall down.
All the rooms/cottages had spongy floors with a laminated probably put down on top of original rotten wood. Makes me shiver.
But nice.
Food was good, breakfast great.
Oh, I forgot the locks on the room doors - the dead bolt on ours didn't work and someone walked in around 1 am. Scarry.
But, quaint!
But anyway, enjoy it, just make sure your insurance is all paid up.

Best place to have a dinner party!!!!!
Reviewed 4 months ago

We just celebrated my sister’s 50th birthday at The Three Village Inn with 20-something of our closest family and friends. We had a beautiful room. The service and food was excellent. The caterer is super easy to work with. And the manager, Danny Laffitte is amazing and personally makes sure your dinner party is perfect & everything is top notch. We can’t say enough about him and the customer service he provides to you during the planning process of your event, as well as on the evening of your party. The valet is also included and terrific. They all were super professional and friendly. From the moment you enter the Inn to the time you leave, it is a wonderful memorable experience. If you are planning a party just need a special place for lunch or dinner - this is definitely a place to book. You will not be disappointed!!!!

Awesome!
Reviewed 6 months ago

Wonderful place. Quiet charming, excellent rooms, old time East Coast flair. Fireplaces and restaurant cute and charming. I would recommend it to anybody who is looking for an old European feel-stay in the USA.

A quiet bit of country on Long Island's north shore
Reviewed 6 months ago

The Three Village Inn is located in Stony Brook on Long Island's north shore, about halfway to Orient Point, the island's north fork. It is a quiet little respite from the hubbub and stresses of the big city to the west, about two hours from Manhattan by car assuming non-rush-hour traffic, which is always difficult to predict. I grew up on Long Island but haven't lived there in 30 years. Instead, my wife and I took a foreign transfer to Tokyo where we've lived since, only coming home to New York once every few years to visit relatives, catch up with old friends and relive old memories. We had our honeymoon in the Three Village Inn in 1987 but haven't seen it since. We were happy to see that it hadn't changed much in that time beyond new paint and some minor renovations to the cottages.

Originally known as the Old Homestead, the Three village Inn was built in 1751 by Richard Hallock. In 1835 it was bought by Jonas Smith, a prominent ship owner, for use as a summer house and it served in that capacity for a succession of owners until 1929 when Mrs. Frank Melville converted it into a Women's Exchange. In the 1930s she opened a tea room and later that decade, a restaurant with rooms for overnight guests. Today it is run as a country inn, has 27 rooms and four cottages, and is open year round to individual guests as well as private functions for up to 200 people.

It is a lovely old place rich in nautical history as is much of the island's north shore. The rooms and cottages are reasonably priced in off-peak seasons, more expensive in December for the holidays. We did not see the rooms but our one-room cottage was spacious and simply appointed with antique furniture and a distinctly New England flavor. Our cottage also had a working gas-powered fireplace which you turned on with a wall switch -- very welcome in cold weather but not too much heat comes from it so it could be used in temperate seasons as well. Service is polite but laid back and not overly swift. There is a fine restaurant with New England seafood dishes on the menu. We had broiled salmon and almond trout and both were delicious. During off-season in mid-week both the bar and restaurant have few patrons making conversations private and romantic. Piped in 60s music seemed to be the theme while we were there. I'm told they do more business on weekends for weddings and receptions so mid-week is a good time to go if you want to avoid the crowds. Stony Brook Harbor is within view of the hotel's front door and some of the rooms, and the nearby town of Stony Brook has many shops that look like they haven't changed much in 75 years. Many fine old colonial houses are in the area as well. It's all very New England without being period pretentious. There is history to be explored as well but, alas, we didn't have time for that. We were, however, there in early November and the trees were in fine color. Take your time on the drive north from the Long Island Expressway as the roads are very beautiful that time of year.