80%
Members Recommend
4.0
Very Good 8471 Reviews
Jetsetter Approved
This Hotel meets our standards
This hotel meets our standards, but we haven't stayed yet

What We Love

  • Sea views from your private balcony Aromatherapy, facials, or massages at Spa Al Mare
  • Conch chowder and other local fare served on the shore at Sun-Sun, the on-site restaurant

What To Know

  • Rooms near the pool can get loud
  • 4PM check-in is on the late side
  • Valet parking costs $25 overnight

Amenities

  •  Babysitting
  •  Bar
  •  Free WiFi
  •  Gym
  •  Handicap Accessible
  •  Parking On Site
  •  Pet-friendly
  •  Pool
  •  Restaurant
  •  Room Service
  •  Spa
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
Florida Hip Hotels Lounge Luxury Modern living room property Lobby Suite home lighting condominium mansion Villa

Overview

Historic Gatsby-era hotel on the largest private beach on Key West

The Lowdown

Casa Marina opened on New Year’s Eve 1920 and although the 311-room Waldorf Astoria property has been fully renovated, the party hasn’t stopped since—there’s a 1,200 square foot beach (and the opportunity to jet ski, sail, or kayak) and two pools for day time hijinks, with Sun-Sun, an oceanfront restaurant, serving the catch of the day and other local specialties at night. Along with sunning and sailing, spa-ing is an option too, with everything from aromatherapy to reflexology on offer. And did we mention the 6,500-square foot, 18-hole golf course on site?

In the Area

Nothing is very far away from anything else on the four-mile island of Key West (which is only 90 miles from Cuba). On one side, the resort is bordered by the sea, which means boat trips, clear bottom kayaks, paddleboarding and parasailing. On the other is Key West’s Old Town, with all its attractions, including the nightlife and restaurants of Duval Street (which is a mile from the resort), and local landmarks such as The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum and the Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory. And if visitors ever run out of things to do on the island (a virtual impossibility), then the Dry Tortugas National Park is 70 miles away by boat or seaplane.

How to Get There

Casa Marina, A Waldorf Astoria Resort
1500 Reynolds Street
Key West, FL 33040 United States

Reviews

4.0 Very Good 8471 Reviews
No Way Hilton’s Luxury Brand “Waldorf Astoria” more like Cheap Motel - $
map1294

As you see from attached. We were placed in some old part of the building that Waldorf must have (all I can think of) purchased old Motel and just did a bolt on to the Original Waldorf. Don't get me wrong, I am sure the Original part maybe nice (doubt it but not as bad as the bolt on), which I can see from other customer Pic’s. but this is not what they gave me. And what's worse is all the linen and towel, that is used for rooms is kept outside.

It is a true shame this resort is earns less then 1-star rating on my behalf. I have stayed at lots of Hilton properties and this I must say is the far worst and for what they charge $$$$. The "luxury" Brand as Hilton calls it is "NOT” has completely deteriorated. The room was just appalling. There was a dirty, stained towel on the floor, the furniture was FULL of nicks. There was dust/visible mold. The prices they charge merit the rooms be in pristine condition, especially carrying the Waldorf logo. And me talking to both Snr. Front Desk management Melisa is the worst (lied on many occasions and I called her out). Ana is also same.

Melisa was the one checked me in, and said I booked King. I said no, there must be some mistake, I booked two beds. and I am sure this is when she changed me and also, I strongly believe she racially profiled and put me in the worst room initially 409 and I had to call her. After two attempts she moved us to 421 not any better, but at least the shower worked here.

As I recall Hilton has inspections and so my question how does this so called "Luxury" brand pass the inspection. I hope Corporate looks at this review and fire Anna and GM. These people are not doing their job.

Two days we had no Housekeeping they come knocking on the door 8:30am. People are on Vacation; this is not business Hotel. And after that they never come back.

Hope someone can seriously look at this Hotel from overall prospective and awaiting some positive response and comp. Mr. John Trovato as Managing Director of both the historic Casa Marina Resort and The Reach, in Key West, Florida. You need to really think about your management. Also, Taj Bhandal - Complex Director of Front Office needs to check on employees like Melisa (who are really great at zero customer service and off course the untruth they speak).

This is not Waldorf Astoria quality HORRIBLE HOTEL
FamilyVacationx4

We have had reservations to stay at this hotel two times. Last summer we were initially placed in the “west wing”. Immediately upon arrival, the room was filthy. The floor was so dirty that when I used a white washcloth to wipe up some spilled water, the washcloth became black. My husband took the washcloth to the front desk and complained about the unsatisfactory condition of the room. We were placed in a room in the main building. The room was old but much better. The cleanliness was somewhat improved and we enjoyed the remainder of our stay.
We made a 2nd reservation at the Casa Marina Waldorf for July 2019. We made the reservation several months in advance and made a specific request with a hotel manager that we did not want to be in the “west wing” but wanted a room in the main building. My husband is a Hilton Honors Lifetime Diamond member. This status is only earned after staying in Hilton hotels over 1000 nights. That means my husband has stayed over 1000 nights in a Hilton brand hotel. It also means he has a specific profile and has earned the right to be treated with the utmost level of customer service at a Hilton property. Regardless, we were placed in a handicapped accessible room (not needed) next to the elevator and across from the ice machine. So, a reservation made months in advance by a Hilton Honors lifetime diamond member who is a return customer, is given one of the worst possible rooms in the main building.
When we complained about the room we were given no workable solution by the hotel manager. The reception clerk basically walked away, the manager never spoke to us, and the young man who tried to help resolve the situation was unable to provide us with an acceptable room. We had to leave the property. NOT THE WAY TO START A KEY WEST VACATION!
BOTTOM LINE: THIS HOTEL IS DIRTY WITH TERRIBLE MANAGEMENT AND CUSTOMER SERVICE!! THE WEST WING SHOULD BE BULLDOZED! If you still want to try it, insist on the main building and insist to not be in a handicapped room next to the elevator and ice machine. Then call multiple times to confirm your requests are being honored. If you get there and have a problem, the managers don’t have the professionalism to come out of their office and talk to you, probably because they have so many issues. In the hour in which we stood at the check in desk trying to have our issues resolved, multiple guests came down to complain about the condition of their rooms.
This hotel should not be called a Waldorf unless they change their cleanliness and improve their customer service. The Hampton Inn in Port St Lucie, Fl where we stayed the first night of our trip (while in transit) was cleaner than the Casa Marina Waldorf.

Going Downhill Rapidly & Trying to Relive a Bygone Era
BANORTHFLORIDA

From what I am told, there is new ownership of this hotel. In my opinion, it is certainly not for the better. Beautiful looking hotel from the outside but with the exception of the pool, that is it on the good side. My suite room was dark and small with the only view to the street. They style of the furnishings in the room were from the 60's or early 70's and had not been replaced since then. Furnishings were old and visibly beat up. Room in general was terrible.
These days, hotels offer coffee in the lobby or at a common place for free as much as you want. Not here, $14 for a pot of coffee - are you kidding me? When asked why no free coffee the response was, "We are the Waldorf Astoria" said with a certain amount of snobbery.
Wifi was not working when I called the front desk on Friday afternoon. Explanation was "they worked on it today and the contractor went home." Tried again Saturday afternoon, same explanation and will not be fixed today.
Looks to me like this place is only concerned with $$ IN but not willing to provide the services of a high class hotel. Will never stay here again.