4.0
Very Good 84 Reviews
Jetsetter Approved
This Hotel meets our standards
This hotel meets our standards, but we haven't stayed yet

What We Love

  • The perfect escape from the city – a vintage-inspired retreat in the hip Catskills town of PhoeniciaThe complimentary bikes, to help you explore the area
  • The Catskills, a brilliant setting for skiing in winter, hiking in summer and year-round antiquing
  • The fun you can have on the property, by the pool or at events like organized bonfires
bathroom sink home cabinetry Kitchen plumbing fixture tile Bath tiled

Overview

A stylish stay at a retro-chic boutique hotel in the Catskill Mountains, with complimentary rental bikes

The Lowdown

Boutique hotel, repurposed motel, a Brooklyn in the mountains – whatever you want to call it, The Graham & Co. has brought hipster style to the Catskills by updating the classic weekend getaway for 21st-century tastes. This escape has transformed a small-town stay into a chic, vintage-inspired retreat, with crisp white walls, kitschy-chic furnishings and funky details, including industrial lighting and wall antlers. It’s just like going to summer camp all over again, but a grown-up summer camp with a strong curatorial flair.
 
Winner of a TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence, this property is a favorite among city dwellers on their days off. You’re within driving distance of antique shops, galleries and restaurants, and there’s lots of fun to be had at home, as well. With a pool that looks straight out of a mid-century hotel, complimentary bikes for charting the surroundings, nightly bonfires for cozy mingling and sometimes movie screenings in the yard, the retreat gives you no shortage of fun things to do. Or just settle into a chair and take in the views, because the rugged Catskills never looked so hip as from this neck of the woods.

Rooms

These hipster-chic rooms have just the right balance of camp and higher-end rustic style. Between the wooden furnishings, crisp white walls, industrial lighting, vintage-inspired accessories and cozy blankets, fit for snuggling by the outside bonfire, no minimalist detail has gone unnoticed. Don’t be surprised to find antlers on the wall, an authentic fur rug on the ground or a picnic table. Regardless of whether your room features one of these, though, it will hold a Tivoli radio with an iPod dock and a private bath.Standard Single rooms, with one queen bed, are the coziest of the lot, while the Standard Doubles are very spacious and hold two queen beds. Deluxe Double rooms, also with two queen beds, are even bigger and occupy a prime location near the pool and fireside activities. In addition, you’ll have a kitchenette and full access to the pool and grounds.

Location

In the heart of the Catskills, Phoenicia, near Woodstock, is the perfect place to weekend away from the city if you’re looking to relax, enjoy the New York countryside and take it easy in a small town with big outdoor adventure. With hiking, tubing and skiing, plus galleries, shops, restaurants and a dive bar, this fresh-air destination is just what the doctor ordered. And if you want to see the city, NYC is just a couple hours away by car (or the Trailways Bus).

How to Get There

The Graham & Co.
80 Route 214
Phoenicia, NY United States

Reviews

4.0 Very Good 84 Reviews
yikes - bad hospitality, bad room, bad value
Reviewed 4 months ago

we had high hopes for our stay at the Graham & Co. -- it seems to always sell out for summer weekends so we booked an august weekend the previous december. But our stay fell way short of what we expected across all important areas...

Hospitality
The staff was un-helpful (we assumed the giant sign behind the front desk that says "don't bother me, I'm local" was meant to be ironic but it turned out to be sincere..). We were never even greeted -- there was a sign on the front door that said which room was ours and that was it. How about a bottle of water? Nope.

Room
Really bad -- a renovated motel room but with a hipster aesthetic that is about 8 years past its prime (i.e. not cool anymore). There was carpet and it felt dirty. We had one of the private rooms. Some of our friends stayed in the "bunk house" which was even worse. Like a gross motel 6 hostel for well north of $200 / night.

Amenities
The pool was decent but the rest was pretty disappointing. We were looking forward to the camp fire but the person at the front desk wouldn't set it up saying it was too damp even though the skies were clear before ultimately relenting and building the fire. They also price gouge for things like tooth brushes (I think they were charging $7 for something that's usually free in a hotel that costs this much..). The wifi was really spotty which was fairly annoying since there's no cell service.

Main takeaway - #1 it's not a hotel. It's a motel. #2, don't believe the hype or be fooled by nice instagram photos. Not worth $250 a night at all (is any motel?) -- the owners are laughing all the way to the bank. Next time I go to this area I plan to try the Emerson Resort which has the same amenities (nice campfire, pool) but looks way nicer and clean.

Positives and negatives
Reviewed 5 months ago

Very friendly, helpful staff. The room we reserved did not have AC, which my friend needed as she has asthma. They changed us to a bunk house room with AC. However, that room was tiny, with the bathroom down the hall. We were the only ones in the bunk house, so it was tolerable. Location is good, easy walk or bike (they are free) to town. Pool is nice, and we enjoyed the bonfire at night.. This is an older motel that was re-done by some artsy people, so if you prefer design over comfort, this may be enjoyable for you. They list free breakfast on the website, but they only serve it Sat/Sun. Not a great value.

Modern mountain motel!
Reviewed 6 months ago

The Graham & Co is a great place to stay in Phoenicia. Around a dozen rooms, smartly updated in 2013 from an old motor lodge so retains some rustic charm but has great toiletries, details and wifi. Reception area has coffee, fruit, nuts in the morning. There's a fire pit at the picnic tables and another with seating area beyond the swimming pool. Or you can rest in a hammock under the trees! Located near one end of Main Street, you can borrow a bike or walk to restaurants, shops, hiking trials or tubing. Highly recommended and will definitely make a return visit.

A Bear of a Bad Time
Reviewed 6 months ago

We booked a room eight months ago for a wedding. Our room was tiny and the rug was dirty. It reminded us of $20 motels we stayed in 50 years ago. No television and no refrigerator. There was internet service but it was sporadic. For $235 per night we expected much much better. My wife brought food back to the hotel from two meals. The reception person told her to leave it in the Den, a small shack around 60 feet from our room even though there was a refrigerator in the Reception building. The next day I noticed the Den refrigerator was empty. The reception person gave me a perfunctory “I am sorry”. Another person working there then said that a bear had entered the Den, broken into the Refrigerator and took the food. That person also gave a perfunctory “I am sorry”.

Was there a sign anywhere about bears? No.
Did the hotel orally warn us about bears being in the area? No.
So the bear broke into a presumably closed building just 60 feet from our room.

The breakfast was very nice as was the swimming pool area.

Worth $235 a night? No
Would we recommend this place? No. The other wedding guests concur.

Totally hipster cool getaway hangout
Reviewed 7 months ago

Whe we first arrived at this little hotspot we were a tiny but daunted by its quiet verging on cold (in style and staff) reception. That colour scheme of the room seems to centre itself around grey and the people round the pool all looked like they were in moods with each other BUT once evening hit and we'd hired the complimentary bikes and had a swim and settled round the communal bonfire things definitely felt friendlier and cosy and possibly the nicest time of all was waking up and leaving our bedroom door ajar with sun coming streaming in and the sound of people tottering over to the reception hut for coffee. It was truly totally chilling out and lovely. Slight problem with the lack of tempting eateries - we did venture to the Pheonix Diner which was great but not the best diner in the world (much prefer not to have modernisations on diner classics) but there was a full working kitchen in our room so you can knock up your own picnic or supper. And such a shame that the fabulous old fashioned drug store was closing down as we there - managed to snap up some 1970s watch straps before it did. There is a fantastic vintage shop called the Mystery Spot to browse in and we were desperate to do the railroad attraction but that seemed to have closed down as well! So basically take a lot of books and just hang out and enjoy. I like that they've kept some of the character of the rooms and I think the bathrooms may have the original features which I really appreciate but it could just do with a little more warmth to it and it would be perfect. (I have put that we travelled in 2017 but I actually think it was 2016 and I just forgot to trip advise at the time so am catching up!) p.s. nice little gift shop!