91%
Members Recommend
4.5
Very Good 25 Reviews
Jetsetter Verified
This Hotel meets our standards
Our editors have been here and it has met our standards

What We Love

  • Inspired rustic-chic design incorporates hand-picked local antiques, original Pop Art, reclaimed materials and spa-worthy amenities
  • Practically within stone-skipping distance of the Delaware River (rafting, canoeing, kayaking, tubing and swimming await)
  • The affable owners regularly invite guests over for drinks in their reimagined 19th-century church-cum-fantasy-home, just next door
  • The hotel is gay-friendly

What To Know

  • The owners’ cheeky sense of humor may not appeal to all guests (e.g., the inn name’s wordplay on “stick it in” or certain expletive-laced artworks)
  • No kids (under 18) or pets are allowed
  • Cell service is spotty, so you may have to rely on the (free) house phone for your calls

Amenities

  •  Adults Only
  •  Free WiFi
  •  Parking On Site
Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.
Adult-only Budget Hip Inn Outdoor Activities Rustic property living room home Suite cottage Bedroom leather

Overview

Design-heavy digs redefine country house retreat at this intimate Catskills riverfront inn

The Look

Tucked away in the sleepy Catskills hamlet of Barryville, NY, the intimate Stickett Inn offers a sophisticated, design-centric retreat in the heart of the countryside for some grown-up R&R. Founded in 2013 by style-savvy New York City transplants Roswell Hamrick (a TV/film production designer) and Johnny Pizzolato (co-owner of NYC fashion boutique International Playground), the formerly dilapidated 1830s canal house has been gutted, renovated and passionately reinvented as sleek guest quarters that are chock-full of inspired design and spa elements.

Bed and Bath

Four airy living room/bedroom suites are named for signature features (“Eat,” “Soak,” “Drink” and “Steam”), but they share common elements such as original wide-plank wood flooring, artwork by rotating resident artists like Trey Speegle and hand-picked local antiques. Splashes of Japanese wallpaper, reproduction vintage light fixtures, and reclaimed metal, wood and stone enliven the design. Book the “Soak” suite for its cold plunge–ready galvanized trough tub, or the “Eat” for its full kitchen and private dining balcony. All suites come with memory foam beds trimmed with hand-dyed Upstate bedding, wine fridges, iPod docking stations and Malin + Goetz bath amenities.

Beyond

On the second floor a shared hallway station offers guests free espresso, ice and access to a house phone (a plus, since cell reception is spotty). Out front, there’s a reception/juice bar/hotel shop hybrid (open Thursdays through Sundays). Pick up fresh-pressed juices and lunch fare like burritos, fresh guacamole and salads; you can also browse hotel-branded souvenirs, assorted travel conveniences and regional wares and curiosities. Out back, a cheery common courtyard beckons guests to its eight-person hot tub, BBQ grill and firepit. Or sink into one of the pair of front porch hammocks for a lazy sway looking out at the town’s main drag, in the direction of the Delaware River. For a one-of-a-kind encounter, the inn’s imaginative owners (along with their Brussels Griffon pup) regularly invite guests for cocktails and to tour their magazine-spread-worthy hillside fantasy home, set in a repurposed 19th-century church.

In the Area

Go for a dip in the Delaware River, or head out with outfitter Reber River Trips for canoeing, kayaking, rafting and tubing adventures. (Stickett Inn guests get a 15 percent discount.) Cross the bridge to Shohola, Pennsylvania, where the stuck-in-time dive bar Rohman’s Inn (former haunt of such celebs as Bette Davis) features an unmissable antique manual bowling alley. Stock up on breakfast and lunch fare to go at the River Market grocery, across the street (also the site of a farmers market on Saturdays), or book a table at the farm-to-table eatery Henning’s Local, in Eldred.

How to Get There

Stickett Inn
3380 Route 97
Barryville, NY 12719 United States

Reviews

4.5 Very Good 25 Reviews
Catering for a Memorial Service
Reviewed 1 month ago

Roswell and Johnny not only catered my father's memorial service, but facilitated the tent, table and chairs delivery for us. We live on LI and hosted at a weekend house in Barryville. Roswell and Johnny took care of everything for us. Their cook, Pam, is the BEST. The food was awesome, the service spectacular and an uncomfortable situation was made so much easier for us. I can't thank them enough and will be going there MORE for the burritos and tacos! They're the best!!

Love this place!
Reviewed 4 months ago

My husband and I stayed here for a wedding a few months back and absolutely loved our experience. The owners, Johnny & Roswell made us feel right at home and helped us get settled into our new digs. Our room was HUGE and beautifully decorated. We both slept great on their super comfortable beds and took advantage of all of the fancy soaps in the bathroom.

We ended up going kayaking a few blocks away, which was a nice tip from the inn, and we dined at their taco joint afterwards. The food was super tasty and hit the spot after paddling away.

Would highly recommend to anyone visiting the Barryville area. But, beware, this place is very true to it's name. Within minutes of us returning we found out that we were expecting (not a joke). The Stickett Inn really works!

In desperate need of some TLC
Reviewed 5 months ago

Recently stayed in the cottage at Stickett Inn. While has the potential to be absolutely wonderful, the grounds are neglected, hot tub in need attention. Loved the retro kitsch of the cottage, but accommodations are in desperate need of a good cleaning, pillows and linens in need of replacement. Pinks Taco and bar on the grounds is a plus, staff there were wonderful.

Adorable Inn
Reviewed 6 months ago

Had an amazing weekend get away with my husband here. The Inn is adorable with a bar / cafe on location. The staff was so welcoming and helpful.
In walking distance to the Delaware River where you can raft or float down the river on a tube. The local market only also in walking distance.

Would Stickett Inn Again
Reviewed 1 year ago

We adored this place. Super cute, super clean, and super quirky. Everything was immaculate and so much fun to look around at. Our beds were extremely comfortable and we had no issue feeling right at home. Roswell was a fantastic host from booking to check out. The four of us will 100% return for hopefully a longer stay at the Stickett Inn.